Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Title: Incommensurabilities in the work of Thomas Kuhn
Authors: Demir, Ipek
First Published: Mar-2008
Publisher: Elsevier
Citation: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 2008, 39 (1), pp. 133-142.
Abstract: I distinguish between two ways in which Kuhn employs the concept of incommensurability based on for whom it presents a problem. First, I argue that Kuhn’s early work focuses on the comparison and underdetermination problems scientists encounter during revolutionary periods (actors’ incommensurability) whilst his later work focuses on the translation and interpretation problems analysts face when they engage in the representation of science from earlier periods (analysts’ incommensurability). Secondly, I offer a new interpretation of actors’ incommensurability. I challenge Kuhn’s account of incommensurability which is based on the compartmentalisation of the problems of both underdetermination and non-additivity to revolutionary periods. Through employing a finitist perspective, I demonstrate that in principle these are also problems scientists face during normal science. I argue that the reason why in certain circumstances scientists have little difficulty in concurring over their judgements of scientific findings and claims while in others they disagree needs to be explained sociologically rather than by reference to underdetermination or non-additivity. Thirdly, I claim that disagreements between scientists should not be couched in terms of translation or linguistic problems (aspects of analysts’ incommensurability), but should be understood as arising out of scientists’ differing judgments about how to take scientific inquiry further.
ISSN: 0039-3681
Type: Article
Description: This paper was published as Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 2008, 39 (1), pp. 133-142. It is available from Doi: 10.1016/j.shpsa.2007.11.011
Appears in Collections:Published Articles, Dept. of Sociology

Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.

Items in LRA are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.